The Green Bay Guide: Your 3 favorite pizza parlors

We asked our readers to tell us their favorite Green Bay pizza places. Here’s what they said.

When it comes to the best pizza in Green Bay, the competition is fierce. With so many delicious options to choose from, it can be hard to decide which pizzeria reigns supreme. That’s why we turned to the people of Green Bay to settle the score once and for all. After conducting a readers’ choice poll, the results are in, and Green Bay has spoken! Let’s take a closer look at the top three pizza joints in town.

Getty Images

3. Jake’s Pizza 

Jake’s Pizza has been a staple of the Green Bay pizza scene for 50 years. With a flair for freshness and a dash of innovation, this is not your average pizzeria. While many pizza joints boast fresh-made dough, Jake’s crafts all their dough, sauces, and sausages from scratch. Combined with using the same ovens and processes since 1974, the secret is in taking their time to make the perfect pie every time.

While Jake’s has made it to their golden 50th year, they’re not afraid to mix things up. The menu boasts specialty pizzas that are anything but boring. Not to mention their breads, homemade sauces, and their signature sandwich…

But what truly sets Jake’s apart is the care and craftsmanship that goes into every slice. The crust is neither too thick nor too thin, but just right, allowing the medley of flavors on top to truly shine. It’s a masterpiece of balance and texture that can only come from a deep love and respect for the art of pizza making.

So, if you want to savor a true Green Bay pizza, take a trip to Jake’s. Dive into the delightful culinary favorite that is Jake’s. It’s an experience that you won’t soon forget. 

2. Gallagher’s Pizza

Gallagher’s Pizza has been delighting Green Bay for over 26 years. Each slice from Gallagher’s is made entirely from scratch from the dough to the sauce then topped with locally-sourced Wisconsin cheese and meats. With their unwavering dedication to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and sticking to time-honored recipes while testing out new flavors to surprise and delight, Gallagher’s crafts pies that are both a nod to the past and a wink to the present.

The magic of Gallagher’s begins with their dough, which is prepared fresh daily, offering the perfect foundation for their wide array of toppings. Whether you’re a fan of the classic cheese (plus extra cheese) and pepperoni or you prefer to sample their specialty deep-dish pizzas, Gallagher’s ensures that every bite is a delight. And let’s not gloss over their infamous breadsticks, which have become almost as legendary as the pies themselves. Crunchy and irresistible, they’re the perfect vehicle for Gallagher’s signature marinara sauce.

The menu at Gallagher’s also features a variety of creative pizzas that push the boundaries of tradition. From incorporating locally-sourced ingredients to experimenting with unexpected flavor combinations, Gallagher’s proves that respecting tradition doesn’t mean shying away from modern culinary trends.

At Gallagher’s Pizza, every slice indeed tells a story – one of meticulous ingredient selection, masterful preparation, and an unyielding dedication to creating unforgettable dining experiences. It’s this narrative that has endeared Gallagher’s to the hearts of Green Bay’s pizza aficionados and why it has earned its rightful place among the top contenders for the best pie in the city.

1. Cranky Pat’s

Cranky Pat’s, a Wisconsin institution since 1955, stands out for its years of dedication to crafting the perfect pizza. This place is a local legend that has been whipping up some of the most tantalizing pies around — not to mention offering a fresh salad bar — and earning itself a dedicated following.

Whether you lean towards the timeless charm of a pepperoni pizza or you’re the type to explore the culinary wilderness with a BBQ chicken pizza, Cranky Pat’s menu has a breadth that welcomes all. From pastas to “Cranky Sticks” to sandwiches and stuff for the kids, Cranky Pat’s has something for every craving.

So, what makes Cranky Pat’s a crust above the rest? It’s the combination of mouth-watering pizzas, a cozy and friendly environment, and a commitment to making every visit memorable. While Green Bay might have its fair share of places to grab a slice, Cranky Pat’s has carved out its own slice of the pie, proving time and again that truly great pizza stands the test of time.

MORE FROM THE GREEN BAY GUIDE:

• Best burger
• Best fried chicken
• Best ice cream
• Best cheese destinations