Healthcare

Farmers and small business owners in Wisconsin push for a BadgerCare public option

Wisconsin farmers, advocacy groups, and Democratic lawmakers have pushed for BadgerCare expansion and public option proposals to give small businesses, entrepreneurs, and self-employed workers more affordable health insurance options.

farmer stands on the stairs of a green farm equipment
Having advocated for universal healthcare to protect independent family farms from skyrocketing insurance premiums, Spring Valley farmer Phil Verges is now hopeful that Wisconsin’s newly elected Democratic trifecta will pass a BadgerCare public option. (Photo by Salina Heller)

For 45 years, Phil Verges has watched the ways of rural life in Pierce County bend to the weather, the markets, and the quiet vanishing of neighboring family farms. Verges understands the squeeze. He’s found himself over the years caught in the gap between running a small agricultural operation and securing affordable, reliable health coverage. “As a farmer, that’s important to me,” he said.

For Verges, farming has come with the compromise of absorbing the financial risk without a safety net.

“I’ve recently aged into Medicare,” he told UpNorthNews. “But as that happens, it’s kind of a bittersweet thing because I think back as a farmer, going back 40 years, and you had to buy your own insurance—I was never covered with any other worker compensation.”

At points later in life, Verges had coverage through his wife’s employer. But the thought that other countries enjoyed benefits Americans didn’t have access to, like universal healthcare systems, stood out to him. 

“I was looking at what other countries do and how they provided health coverage to everyone, and I thought for sure here in the US, we’ll have something before I get to Medicare,” he said. “Well, lo and behold, 40 years later, I’m on Medicare, and we still don’t have some form of universal healthcare.”

Verges—who also organizes local agricultural and environmental protections through groups like GrassRoots Organizing Western Wisconsin (GROWW)—now sees a sliver of hope following the November midterm elections, which shifted the balance of political power in Wisconsin for the first time in 16 years, and swept a blue wave across the federal government.

“I think there’s a strong desire and a strong opportunity to provide some form of Medicare for All in the very near future,” Verges said. “That gives me a lot of hope.”

Wisconsin could have expanded Medicaid 13 years ago. What stopped it?

In 2013, Republican Gov. Scott Walker and the Republican-controlled Wisconsin Legislature turned down federal money to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act (ACA).

Under the federal law, the federal government would have paid 100% of expansion costs for the first three years and 90% thereafter—a huge incentive for states to opt into the program. The move would have expanded coverage to adults earning up to 138% of the federal poverty level. 

All of Wisconsin’s neighboring states adopted the expansion, leaving Wisconsin as the sole non-expanding state in the Midwest.

Instead, Walker made changes to BadgerCare Plus, Wisconsin’s Medicaid program, which provides full healthcare coverage to low-income Wisconsin residents ages 0 to 64.

At the time, adults in Wisconsin could earn up to double the official federal poverty line (200%) and still get BadgerCare Plus. But Walker cut that limit in half to 100% of the poverty line. In plain terms, it dropped the annual income limit for an individual to $11,490 and to $23,550 for a family of four.

Because the income limit dropped, somewhere between 62,000 and 77,000 adults who earned just above the poverty line lost their BadgerCare Plus coverage. They would have qualified for the Medicaid expansion being offered by the federal government, but Walker declined.

According to Wisconsin Watch, rejecting the full expansion meant state taxpayers had to pay 39.3% of the costs for covering residents below the poverty line, rather than the 10% share states pay under full federal expansion. 

After taking office in 2019, Democratic Gov. Tony Evers included full BadgerCare expansion (to 138% federal poverty limit) in his 2019–21, 2021–23, and 2023–25 budget proposals. But each time, the Republican-controlled Joint Finance Committee stripped the provision out.

In February 2025, Evers introduced full BadgerCare expansion for a fourth budget. The Wisconsin Department of Health Services projected the move would extend coverage to 95,800 additional residents and save the state $1.9 billion over two years. But Republican lawmakers again removed Medicaid expansion from the final 2025–27 state budget.

Also in 2025, President Donald Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act was signed into law. It ended the Medicaid expansion offer from the federal government for any states that hadn’t yet accepted it. That legislation officially took effect in January 2026.

In the November 2026 elections, Democrats won control of both the governor’s office and the state legislature for the first time in 16 years. But Gov.-Elect David Crowley said expanding Medicaid for Wisconsinites wouldn’t be realistic without the financial incentive that the federal government had previously offered.

Instead, newly elected state leaders are looking into creating a state-run health insurance exchange to help lower costs for people struggling just above the poverty line.

The need for state-driven healthcare reforms

Back in March, Rep. Tara Johnson (D-Town of Shelby) introduced a BadgerCare Public Option bill that Republicans didn’t even entertain in committee hearings, let alone floor votes. Once the new lawmakers are seated in January 2027, however, a public option could be back on the table..

Wisconsin State Rep. Ryan Spaude (D-Ashwaubenon) said a public option would allow the state to set up its own health insurance exchange and let higher-income residents and small businesses with 50 or fewer employess buy into BadgerCare directly.

“In Wisconsin, we had to get a little more creative,” Spaude said. “A public option is more competition.”

Incoming lawmakers are echoing the urgency for state-driven healthcare reforms, particularly in rural areas. Assemblyman-elect Ben Gruber (D-Arena), a conservation warden who flipped the 51st Assembly District in southwestern Wisconsin by defeating longtime Republican incumbent Todd Novak, said rising costs and hospital closures have left rural communities behind.

“For far too long, we have watched our family farmers struggle, our Main Street business close, and families neglect basic healthcare due to skyrocketing insurance costs and closed rural clinics and hospitals,” Gruber told UpNorthNews.

“Corporate greed and legislative inaction have cost lives so CEOs and Wall Street can rake in billions in profits.”

Gruber agreed with Spaude that Wisconsin cannot rely on Washington to fix the state’s coverage gaps.

“Unfortunately, the federal government has proven over and over again that it is unwilling to solve the healthcare crisis, and it is beyond time for the state to step in,” Gruber said. “I don’t know what the exact solution is yet, but it is abundantly clear that what we are doing is not working for Wisconsin, and I look forward to getting to work after I am inaugurated in January to come up with an affordable solution for Wisconsin that supports the health of everybody in this state.”

As policymakers debate, Wisconsinites delay care

Bill Hogseth, co-executive director of GROWW, said his organization spent June, July, and August speaking directly with residents about the mounting healthcare challenges in the region. Following the recent closures of two hospitals, roughly 15 clinics, and local birthing centers in the Chippewa Valley, Hogseth said the current healthcare model is failing local families.

“People cannot get the care they need because our healthcare system is designed to make a small set of shareholders rich instead of delivering care,” he told UpNorthNews. “The priorities are mismatched.”

GROWW and allied groups—including Citizen Action of Wisconsin and the Wisconsin Public Education Network—are advocating for a shift in state policy. 

However, Hogseth said passing such reforms will require lawmakers to challenge powerful lobbying interests, specifically naming the Wisconsin Hospital Association as a major political donor in the state.

“Again, it comes back to this tension between the agenda of regular people and the agenda of big money politics,” Hogseth said. “So it’s like big-tent politics versus big money politics.”

Hogseth said opening the state-run program to the broader public would introduce much-needed competition to the private insurance market, eliminate executive profit markups, and provide families with predictable, lower-cost coverage.

Dr. Rita Simon, a retired family physician from Chippewa Falls and member of Citizen Action of Wisconsin, said preventative care is essential to reversing declining national health trends. She said a statewide healthcare affordability survey from the Consumer Healthcare Experience State Survey (CHESS), conducted in Wisconsin by the Altarum Healthcare Value Hub found more than half the people in the state haven’t gotten the care they need.

“Over the past year, 52% of Wisconsinites have said that they delayed or skipped medical care due to cost, and most of them were insured,” Simon said. “It’s because of their well-founded fears of becoming financially burdened with unaffordable deductibles, co-pays, and costly uncovered medications.”

“As a family practice physician, (I know) we need to be there when people are sick, but more importantly, we need to be there when folks are well and to help them stay well so they can enjoy childhood, raise families, have a satisfying, productive work life, and enjoy living in this beautiful world as long as possible.”

READ MORE: WI colon cancer survivor faces a $20K health insurance spike


Categories:

Authors

  • A former 15-year veteran of reporting local news for western Wisconsin TV and radio stations, Salina Heller also volunteers in community theater, helps organize the Chippewa Valley Air Show, and is kept busy by her daughter’s elementary school PTA meetings. She is a UW-Eau Claire alum.