Economy

Here’s why Wisconsin heating bills are likely going up this winter

A national forecast projects a $66 increase in winter heating spending at the same time that Wisconsin utility customers face higher electricity rates.

Photo of a man in heavy winter clothing using a mobile snowblower in Wisconsin.
Photo credit: Aaron of L.A. Photography/Shutterstock

Before Kate Gordon advised the US energy secretary for the Biden administration, she learned a simple lesson about keeping a Wisconsin home warm in the winter.

“I grew up in Wisconsin,” said Gordon, now CEO of California Forward, a nonpartisan nonprofit organization focused on building a sustainable state economy. “We used to put putty in the cracks in our windows.”

With heating costs projected to rise this winter, finding ways to keep warmth from escaping could become even more important for households struggling to pay their bills.

The National Energy Assistance Directors Association (NEADA), an energy advocacy organization, projects the average US household will spend an average of $1,002 on heating this winter—$66 more than last year, a 7.1% increase.

The forecast comes as Wisconsin customers are already facing higher electricity rates, with We Energies and Wisconsin Public Service seeking further increases over the next two years.

Gordon is now based in California. She said higher heating costs are landing on top of expenses that already leave households stretched thin.

“For some people, it might not seem like a lot to have an increase,” she said. “But that is a big chunk of money for a lot of Americans.”

NEADA’s Executive Director Mark Wolfe issued a similar message.

“For higher-income households, these increases may be an inconvenience. For low- and middle-income families, they can be devastating,” he said in a statement. “Families are already struggling with rising costs for food, housing and other necessities. Adding hundreds or even thousands of dollars to their winter heating bills will push many of them further into debt.”

Different fuels, different pressures

NEADA projects winter heating costs will remain stable for households using natural gas, but will increase by 6% for electricity and 5% for propane customers. 

Wisconsin and other Midwestern states rely primarily on natural gas for heating, with propane playing an important role in rural areas, according to NEADA. The region’s cold winters can require a significant use of energy.

Heating oil users will face the largest projected increase at 70.2%, which the association attributes largely to higher global oil prices associated with the Iran war.

“What’s happening right now with home heating oil is different from what’s happening with natural gas, and that’s different from what’s happening with electricity,” Gordon said.

Although heating oil prices have recently declined, NEADA warned that instability in the Strait of Hormuz and uncertainty about global oil supplies could elevate prices through the winter, with households spending an average of $2,977 on heating oil compared with $1,749 last winter.

Adding insult to injury, Gordon said electricity costs could also go up, due to the expense of repairing and expanding an aging grid that now has increased  demands from manufacturing, air conditioning, and data centers.

Wisconsin electricity rates have already increased

Wisconsin households are entering into the chilly season with electricity-rate increases already approved for two of the state’s largest utilities. 

In November 2024, the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin approved electricity rate increases for We Energies and Wisconsin Public Service for 2025 and 2026—raising monthly bills by about $10 for We Energy customers and $5 for Wisconsin Public Service customers, on average. 

A spokesperson for WEC Energy Group, which owns both utilities, told Wisconsin Public Radio the decision supported investment to reduce outages, build infrastructure, and meet federal environmental rules. He urged customers concerned about their bills to contact the utilities about assistance and payment plans.

Who pays for a changing grid?

Gordon said the debate over energy costs comes down in part to responsibility: How much should households pay, and what share should fall to utility shareholders, taxpayers, and large electricity users?

“The bottom line is that this stuff costs money, and somebody is paying for it,” she said.

Gordon noted that investor-owned utilities operate for-profit, even though public regulators oversee their rates. She said decisions made by the utilities consider both the burden on customers as well as returns to shareholders. And issues like welcoming large data centers onto the grid are emerging—Gordon suggested that companies building those data centers should be contributing fairly to the infrastructure needed to serve them.

But helping households afford energy requires more than deciding who pays for infrastructure. Gordon said it also means reducing the amount of energy homes need and limiting their exposure to volatile fuel prices.

Help with heating bills is available

Wisconsin’s Home Energy Assistance Program, known as WHEAP, is accepting applications for the heating season though May 15. Eligible households can receive a one-time regular payment toward heating and electric costs.

The benefit is intended to cover a portion of energy expenses rather than the entire bill. Residents can call 1-866-HEATWIS, or 1-866-432-8947, for information about applying.

In a September statement, Mark Wolfe from NEADA urged Congress to increase funding for home energy assistance programs nationwide from $4 billion to $7 billion.

“Congress cannot wait for the first cold snap,” Wolfe said in the statement. “Energy is not a luxury. We can modernize the grid and meet growing demand without pushing families into crisis, but affordability has to be a key element of those decisions.”

Assistance can help households pay their bills in the short-term, but Gordon said making homes more energy efficient can help reduce those costs over time.

“One of the most obvious and important is just weatherization,” Gordon said. “If you’re losing a whole bunch of heat from your house because your house isn’t adequately insulated, or it’s got gaps—you know, in the window frames and under your doors—you are seeing money go out the door, literally.”


Categories:

Authors

  • Jessica F. Simmons is a Reporter & Strategic Communications Producer for COURIER, covering community stories and public policies across the country. Featured in print, broadcast, and radio journalism, her work shows her passion for local storytelling and amplifying issues that matter to communities nationwide.