Culture

Break up with Amazon this holiday season with these 17 Wisconsin-based shops

Skip the cardboard boxes this year. These Wisconsin-based shops are full of locally made gifts, from Door County art to Kohler chocolates.

Wisconsin-based shops
La Belle FDL celebrates hometown pride with a curated collection of Wisconsin-made gifts, many of which come from woman-owned businesses. (La Belle FDL)

Amazon can get a package to your door by Thursday. What it can’t do is know that your sister still talks about Friday fish fry, or that your dad’s happiest place on earth is a cabin Up North. 

Independent Wisconsin-based shops get it. All over the state, owners have packed their shelves with work from local potters, printmakers, cheesemakers, and woodworkers—the kind of gifts that come with a story attached rather than a Prime Day deal. 

Every store on this list is based in Wisconsin. Not everything inside is made here, but most of these shops lean hard on local makers, and several sell nothing else. 

One tip before you hit the road: Hours shift around the holidays, especially in Door County and Up North. Check a shop’s website or social media before you make the drive. 

Wisconsin-based shops in Milwaukee and Ozaukee County 

Milwaukee Makers Marketplace, Milwaukee 

Where: 2625 S. Greeley St., Suite 135, Milwaukee 

For years, the Milwaukee Makers Market was a moving target. It started as a handful of artists in a Bay View parking lot and grew into the city’s biggest and longest-running maker market, popping up everywhere from Discovery World to The Ivy House. 

In September 2024, founder Ryan Laessig finally gave it a permanent address. Milwaukee Makers Marketplace sits on South Greeley Street, just a few blocks from that first market. 

Inside, look for clothing, candles, soap, jewelry, ceramics, and art from local creators. The market’s one big rule applies here, too: Vendors have to make what they sell. The shop is only open Friday through Sunday, so plan accordingly. 

Quirky candles with a local wink are among the Wisconsin-made gifts you’ll discover at Milwaukee Makers Marketplace. (Milwaukee Makers Market)

The Waxwing, Milwaukee 

Where: 2201 N. Farwell Ave., Milwaukee 

When its East Side lease ended in 2020, The Waxwing moved its whole operation online. Six years later, the woman-owned gift shop is back on the Lower East Side with a storefront in the former James May Gallery space, across from the Oriental Theatre. 

Owner Steph Davies sells only handmade goods, with a heavy Milwaukee streak. Expect bath bombs, soy candles, prints and original artwork, canvas bags, food-themed jewelry, and other tchotchkes that make easy gifts for anyone who’s proud of the 414. 

Local delivery is available for online orders over $25. 

Shop for bath salts, socks, soap, and more from local makers at The Waxwing in Milwaukee. (The Waxwing)

Frankie’s, Thiensville 

Where: 184 S. Main St., Thiensville 

Owner Lauran Frank wanted her own gift shop from the time she was a teenager. She finally opened one in her 40s, and Thiensville’s Main Street is better for it. 

Frankie’s stocks goods from more than 60 vendors, ranging from Wisconsin-themed stickers and watercolor books to mosaic Christmas trees and quilted pillow covers. Tucked inside is Frankie’s Book Nook, a tiny bookshop dedicated to Wisconsin authors. 

Pair a novel by a local writer with a candle or tote bag, and you’ve got a gift that’s Wisconsin through and through. 

Inside Frankie’s is a Book Nook that showcases books from Wisconsin-based authors. (Frankie’s)

Locally Inspired, Port Washington 

Where: 302 N. Franklin St., Port Washington 

Kelly Brown spent 12 years in the corporate world but always pictured running a shop of her own. 

In June 2020, she finally went for it, opening Locally Inspired in downtown Port Washington—yes, in the middle of the pandemic. She was motivated by a love of handmade gifts and the stories behind them, and she wanted a space dedicated to Wisconsin makers and small businesses. 

The gamble paid off. The shop has moved twice since then and now stocks more than 2,000 Wisconsin-made products from well over 130 makers. Shelves hold apparel, greeting cards, candles, bath and body products, home decor (look out for Wisconsin shot glasses), and a section for pets and little ones. For a gift with hometown pride, look for the shop’s “For the Love of Port” collection. 

Locally Inspired in Port Washington stocks goods from more than 130 Midwest makers, most of whom are based in Wisconsin. (Locally Inspired)

Madison and Dane County 

Anthology, Madison 

Where: 230 State St., Madison

Madison natives Sachi and Laura Komai opened Anthology on State Street as a place to spark creativity. 

Both artists themselves, the sisters stock the shop with their own work, as well as pieces from local and independent artists, alongside cards, stickers, stationery, and craft supplies. The shop also donates to local nonprofits to get art supplies to kids. 

It’s a goldmine for stocking stuffers, and the obvious stop for the friend who still sends letters by hand. 

Anthology in Madison is the place to go for Wisconsin-made prints and paper goods. (Anthology)

Madison Art Market, Madison 

Where: 5944 Odana Rd., Madison 

Katie and Jake Hawley already ran Picture Salon, a fine art printing business that helps artists produce their work. Then those artists started asking for help selling it, too. 

So when the space next door opened up, the couple took it. Jake has called Madison’s West Side “kind of an art desert,” and Madison Art Market was their answer: a one-stop shop for work by Wisconsin artists. 

Today, more than 90 artists from around the state are represented, working in everything from painting and photography to ceramics, jewelry, and wool and fiber art. The shop also hosts days when featured artists set up in the back to show their work and share their stories, so keep an eye out for those before you go. 

Madison Art Market showcases Wisconsin-based artists like Hilary Christensen, who blends watercolors with bits of discarded plastic to create her landscapes. (Madison Art Market)

Fromagination, Madison 

Where: 12 S. Carroll St., Madison 

No Wisconsin gift list is complete without cheese, and Fromagination has been cutting it to order on the Capitol Square since 2007. 

The European-style shop showcases award-winning Wisconsin artisan cheese, like Uplands’ Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Marieke Mature Gouda, and Roelli’s Little Mountain cheese. It also stocks preserves, chocolates, and charcuterie from Wisconsin producers, so you can build a gift box that’s Dairy State from top to bottom. 

Hosting a holiday party? The shop builds artisan cheese trays for events. 

Fromagination in Madison has just about everything you need to craft the perfect Wisconsin cheese board or box. (Fromagination)

Kismetic Studios, Stoughton 

Where: 171 W. Main St., Stoughton 

Stoughton’s historic Main Street has been on a roll, with new shops and restaurants filling its storefronts. One of the best reasons to make the 25-minute drive from Madison is Kismetic Studios. 

The shelves hold locally handmade goods like kimono-style robes, mini backpacks, slow-cooked mustard, hand-thrown coffee mugs, and seasonally scented soy candles, mostly from Midwest makers. That mix makes it an easy place to build a gift basket. Just pair a pantry treat with a handmade accessory and a card, and you’re done. 

The shop doubles as a working studio. Owner Gigi Gastevich is a textile artist, and she makes her own work in the back half of the space. 

Eastern Wisconsin and Door County 

Kohler Chocolates, Kohler 

Where: 795 Woodlake Rd., Kohler

Yes, that Kohler. The company best known for stylish sinks and bathtubs has been making chocolate since 2007, and, as the story goes, it all started because Herb Kohler couldn’t find a chocolate turtle that met his standards. 

So the company made its own. That pecan, caramel, and chocolate creation became the Terrapin, which is still the signature piece. The lineup has since grown to include snacks like chocolate-covered Wisconsin potato chips and elaborate bonbons in flavors ranging from caramel to bubblegum. 

Find the Kohler Chocolates boutique inside the newly renovated Woodlake Market at The Shops at Woodlake in Kohler. 

Kohler Chocolates are as stunning to look as as they are to eat, and to gift. (Sarah Bisacca)

La Belle FDL, Fond du Lac 

Where: Hotel Retlaw, 1 N. Main St., Fond du Lac

Know someone who moved away from Fond du Lac and still won’t stop talking about it? You’ll find their perfect gift at La Belle FDL.

The boutique sits inside Hotel Retlaw, a downtown landmark built in 1923, and celebrates its hometown, state, and wider region with good-looking, practical everyday goods, 98% of which are produced by woman-owned businesses. 

Expect a mix of Wisconsin-based products and Fond du Lac souvenirs, like Wisconsin Old Fashioned mix, magnetic wooden bottle openers, and plenty of cheese-themed memorabilia.  

Wisconsin-based shops
La Belle FDL celebrates hometown pride with a curated collection of Wisconsin-made gifts, many of which come from woman-owned businesses. (La Belle FDL)

Smith’s Mercantile, De Pere 

Where: 116 N. Broadway, De Pere 

At Smith’s Mercantile (formerly SmithMaker Artisan Co.), the artisans behind the handcrafted goods are affectionately known as the shop’s “smiths.” At least half of what’s on the shelves of this De Pere shop is made in Wisconsin, and the rest comes from small makers around the country. 

That blend of perspectives adds up to a collection that’s both artsy and useful. Look for Wisconsin-themed apparel (there’s Green Bay gear galore), handmade candles and natural soaps, clay-pressed jewelry, and cribbage boards for the card shark in the family. Don’t forget the dog, either. The shop stocks locally made pet treats, shampoo, and collars. 

Owner Ruth Fameree makes a point of not stocking what other local merchants already carry, so Smith’s shelves don’t just repeat what’s down the street. And if your list is long, the shop’s new ice cream counter makes a well-earned halftime break. 

Smith’s Mercantile in De Pere is the place to go for handmade Green Bay gear, including knitted caps, unique tees, and baseball caps. (Smith’s Mercantile)

Blue Moon Emporium, Appleton

Where: 227 E. College Ave., Appleton 

Every white elephant exchange has an unofficial winner, and that gift could easily come from Blue Moon Emporium. 

Owner Jennifer Nowak is a longtime seamstress, artist, and crafter, and she fills her College Avenue shop with work from independent artists and designers around the Fox Cities. Pick something up, and she can likely tell you about the person who made it. 

The selection changes constantly, but expect one-of-a-kind jewelry, quirky home decor, and plenty of Wisconsin pride: supper club-themed T-shirts and sweatshirts, disc golf course maps, holiday ornaments, cookie cutters, and Swedish dish towels for the practical person on your list. 

Supper club-themed apparel and disc golf course maps are just a few of the quirky Wisconsin gifts you’ll find at Appleton’s Blue Moon Emporium. (Blue Moon Emporium)

Jacksonport Cottage Gallery & Gifts, Jacksonport 

Where: 6275 Highway 57, Jacksonport 

Plenty of Door County shops shut down once the fall color fades. Jacksonport Cottage Gallery & Gifts stays open Friday through Sunday in winter, then closes for all of January, making December the perfect time to go. 

The shop fills the main floor of a restored 1860s log cabin with original work from more than 100 artists. Look for paintings, handmade rugs, lighthouse-themed pieces, and its well-known collection of Amish quilts. 

Most of Door County shuts down for winter, but Jacksonport Cottage Gallery & Gifts stays open on weekends for the holidays. (Jacksonport Cottage Gallery & Gifts)

Western and northern Wisconsin 

The Local Store, Eau Claire 

Where: 205 N. Dewey St., Eau Claire 

Not many magazines run a gift shop. Then again, not many magazines know their local creative scene quite like Volume One, which has spent years covering arts and culture in Eau Claire. 

Its shop, The Local Store, opened in 2010 and now fills the first floor of the magazine’s downtown headquarters, putting that insider knowledge to work. Chippewa Valley craftspeople supply art prints, glassware, and apparel, while the pantry shelves and local beer, wine, and spirits cater to the foodie and happy-hour host on your list. 

Before you leave, browse the rotating gallery of local and regional art. Your best gift of the season might be hanging on the wall. 

The Local Store is packed wall to wall with locally inspired gifts. (The Local Store)

Drift Mercantile, La Crosse 

Where: 211 Pearl St., La Crosse 

Pick up a T-shirt at Drift Mercantile, and there’s a good chance it was designed and screen-printed right there in the shop. 

Sisters Dani Peterslie and Azia Thelemann opened Drift in 2017 as their take on the old-fashioned general store. Beyond their own apparel, the shelves hold locally made gifts and art inspired by the bluffs and the Driftless region. The shop even offers free U.S. shipping on online orders over $100. 

Shopkeeping runs in the family: The sisters’ parents founded The Pearl Ice Cream Parlor right next door. Consider a scoop your reward for finishing your list. 

Screen-printed T-shirts are a specialty of Drift Mercantile, though you can find plenty of other locally inspired, locally made gifts here. (Drift Mercantile)

Bayfield Artists’ Guild, Bayfield 

Where: 201 Rittenhouse Ave., Bayfield 

Most visitors know Bayfield as the gateway to the Apostle Islands. Come winter, it’s a quieter place to shop the work of the artists who call the area home, and the Bayfield Artists’ Guild on Rittenhouse Avenue is a prime place to start. 

The guild’s shelves and walls are lined with watercolor and oil paintings, blown glass, jewelry, handmade soaps, baskets, knits, beeswax candles, and rosemaling, a traditional Norwegian decorative painting style. 

Keep in mind that winter hours are Saturdays only, so time your trip north accordingly. 

Handcrafted mugs are among the treasures to be found at Bayfield Artists’ Guild. (Bayfield Artists’ Guild)

Red Bicycle Gift Shoppe, Ashland

Where: 618 Main St. W, Ashland 

No two trips to the woman-owned Red Bicycle Gift Shoppe look quite the same. Work by area artists and crafters—pottery, watercolors, jewelry, baskets, painted furniture—shares the floor with vintage and repurposed finds. 

It’s a fitting stop in a town that calls itself the Historic Mural Capital of Wisconsin. Pair your visit with a stroll past downtown Ashland’s larger-than-life murals.

Red Bicycle Gift Shoppe showcases vintage and repurposed finds alongside its locally made products. (Red Bicycle Gift Shoppe)

This article first appeared on Good Info News Wire and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.

Related: 9 Wisconsin candy shops worth checking out


Categories:

Authors

  • Sarah Bisacca is an Atlanta-based writer specializing in high-end hotels, culinary travel, and the hospitality industry. Her work has appeared in Atlanta magazine, Forbes Travel Guide, Southern Living, and Eater Atlanta, among others. When she’s not crafting her next story, she can be found exploring the metro Atlanta food scene or researching the South’s strange and spooky history. Follow her adventures on her website (sarahbtravelin.com) or on Instagram @sarahb_travelin.