Local

Big-box stores rolled back DEI. Should Wisconsinites shop small instead?

With winter holidays quickly approaching, Wisconsinites and business leaders said supporting small businesses helps grow local communities.

Research shows that when communities spend their money at local small businesses, those dollars often stay in the local economy—and, ultimately, end back in the wallets of members of their own community. (Dean Johnson/The Big Gay Market)

Over the last few weeks, small business owner Jen Steffen said she’s noticed something different about Wisconsinites entering her shop, Bleak Boutique, on Main Street in downtown Oshkosh.  

“Just from my perception, from talking to people who will come into the shop, there’s just been this kind of relaxation, that maybe there is hope, and that things won’t continue to get worse,” Steffen said, adding that some Wisconsinites feel this way because of the “blue wave” hitting the Badger State.

“There’s this palpable feeling that we can now focus on the holidays, our families, and things like that without this massive existential dread,” Steffen said. 

There’s hope, too: This shift could also help small business owners like Steffen earn new customers around the holidays, especially after big corporations like Target and Walmart rolled back diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) workforce and merchandise initiatives in the wake of President Donald Trump’s 2025 executive order, which ended DEI programs at the federal level. 

Related: Wisconsin businesses still hurting as Trump tries new ways to impose tariffs

Steffen believes having products in stores geared toward specific underrepresented groups, like the LGBTQ+ community, is important. And she also said companies rolling back DEI efforts are showing their true colors by prioritizing profits over people and confirming customer suspicions of “rainbow washing”—when a company publicly aligns itself with the LGBTQ+ community on a surface level but not in practice or policy. 

“A lot of the time, it’s just for June, for Pride Month, and then companies go right back to ‘business as usual,’” Steffen said, adding that “slapping a rainbow on something that was manufactured en masse in the same factories that everything else is made in” feels disingenuous. 

“How much of that is really making an impact other than just on the most superficial level?” Steffen said. 

At Bleak Boutique, Steffen and her staff stock locally made products and goods from other small businesses across Wisconsin, with special emphasis on those that are women- and LGBTQ+-owned, all year-round. Their shelves are stacked with “goods for goths with good taste,” like witchy fashion, spooky home decor, and even Steffen’s own line of handcrafted, organic and natural soaps, bath bombs, and body and room sprays with scents inspired by gothic cathedrals and old library books. 

“Smaller businesses can reach out directly to an LGBTQ+- or person-of-color-owned business and say that they want to carry their products, and that could be the biggest sale that they have all month,” Steffen said, describing the tangible impact small businesses can have on their local communities.

Related: The best gift and craft shops in Wisconsin, according to readers

Ollie DiPietro, co-founder of LGBTQ+-focused art market The Big Gay Market (TBGM) in Madison, said DEI policy rollbacks aren’t just impacting big box stores that try to align themselves with underrepresented communities. They’re impacting small businesses in Wisconsin, too. 

“I’ve been seeing this happening in and outside of Madison, where there’s a business with a queer artist, and if they don’t like what the artist is doing, or if it’s ‘too political’ that they have queerness as part of their business, then their stuff gets pulled off the shelves,” they said. 

It’s frustrating to see. It makes me, and I’m sure lots of other LGBTQ+ people, feel disposable. Like having queer stuff there is just a way to make money,” DiPietro said. 

To uplift LGBTQ+ makers and small businesses across Wisconsin, they helped create TBGM in 2021. The monthly market has grown from a small art market in College Grove to now hosting over 250 LGBTQ+- and ally-owned small businesses from across Wisconsin inside the Alliant Energy Center in Madison. 

From ceramic cat flower pots to embroidered cowboy hats to taxidermied bugs, DiPietro said TBGM gives attendees a chance to find unique products they can’t find anywhere else—all while supporting Wisconsin’s local small businesses. 

“I think this is a really good space to show up, bring your art, and have it exposed to a large demographic. It’s good for the artists, but also for the attendees to show up and be like, ‘Oh my gosh, look at all these things people are creating, and look how big the world is,’” they said, adding that the increasing popularity of TBGM has allowed organizers to expand what is offered at the event, like all gender clothing swaps, drag performances, and various workshops. 

“It’s like a cultural experience, at least that’s what I want it to be. I want there to be something for everybody, even for people who don’t have a lot of money to spend,” DiPietro said.

Jason Rae, founder of the Wisconsin LGBT Chamber of Commerce, told UpNorthNews that DiPietro and other event organizers’ work to develop TBGM hasn’t gone unnoticed and has helped give Wisconsinites opportunities to keep money circulating in their local community. 

“When you spend money with a local, diverse-owned business, you’re doing more than just making a purchase. You’re helping support local jobs, you’re helping support other businesses, and the community around you,” Rae said. Research shows that when communities spend their money at a local small business, those dollars often stay in their local economy—and, ultimately, end back in the wallets of members of their own community. 

“When you make that purchase with a diverse-owned supplier, it’s got a tremendous ripple effect across the economy: It’s helping small businesses, it’s helping diverse-owned businesses, it’s helping LGBTQ+- and allied-owned businesses, and it’s making an impact right here and staying here in Wisconsin,” Rae said. 

Follow Bleak Boutique on Facebook and Instagram to learn more about their products and holiday sales happening in-store and online. 

For more information about The Big Gay Market, including their upcoming holiday market on Dec. 18 and 19 at Alliant Energy Center, head over here.

To find more LGBTQ+-owned businesses in Wisconsin, check out the Wisconsin LGBT Chamber of Commerce’s online business directory.

Related: 6 Wisconsin small businesses our readers love

Keep UpNorthNews free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting UpNorthNews?

Every day, our team works to provide Wisconsinites with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local news—not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in Wisconsin, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Pat Kreitlow
Pat Kreitlow Founding Editor
Support our team

Categories:

Authors

  • Lucas Henkel is a Reporter & Strategic Communications Producer for COURIER based in mid-Michigan, covering community stories and public policies across the country. His award-winning work shows his passion for local storytelling and amplifying issues that matter to communities nationwide.