The 15 best custard shops in Wisconsin, according to Yelp

Wisconsin may have hundreds of frozen custard shops, but Yelp users say these are the cream of the crop (literally!). Here’s where you can indulge in the best frozen custard in the state. 

The weather is hot, and the custard is melty (but not too melty; after all, it’s not your run-of-the-mill ice cream). No disrespect to other fabulous frozen treats, but almost everyone agrees that once you try custard, you’ll never go back! For those who haven’t experienced custard before, the difference between that and ice cream might not be clear — so let’s break it down. 

Two of the most significant differences revolve around the ingredients and how it’s prepared. Ice cream (while delicious) is known for being more dense, more frozen, and not super creamy since most contain milk instead of cream. Custard, on the other hand, is a delightful sensory experience like no other. Because custard is made with heavy cream and egg yolks, it’s smoother, creamier, and stored at a warmer temperature.

If you aren’t already a custard connoisseur and are curious to find the best in town, look no further. But don’t just take our word for it — check out these custard shops ranked from 3.1 stars on up according to Yelp to see who has the best custard in Wisconsin. 

Michael’s Frozen Custard, Madison, 3.1 Stars

Address: 3826 Atwood Ave Madison, WI 53714

Price: $$

Why Yelpers Love It: This custard spot is known for its unique and varied flavors – with 21 different sundae options, there is something for everyone. Try an Emerald City Twister with mint custard, brownies, and pecans. “There are so many options! I ended up getting the Flying Monkey which was milk chocolate custard and bananas with peanut butter sauce. Sooo good! There’s so many choices so have fun choosing!” one Yelp reviewer raved. You can either stop in the shop or roll through the drive-thru. 

MooSa’s, Milwaukee, 3.1 Stars

Address: 2272 N Lincoln Memorial Dr Milwaukee, WI 53202

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Near Bradford Beach, you can find MooSa’s with outdoor seating, a pet-friendly location, and of course, delicious food. One Yelper appreciates everything about MooSa’s — from the location to the custard, it’s the place to be. “MooSa’s is such an amazing place. From the food, location, and sweet custard it has everything you need for a day at the beach. I love their custard as it is perfectly rich and smooth. It is right next to Bradford Beach and although it’s a small establishment it is a very comforting ambiance.”

Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard, Muskego, 3.4 Stars

Address: S73W16770 W Janesville Rd Muskego, WI 53150

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Mosey on over to Muskego’s Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard for dinner and a delicious treat. One reviewer enjoyed their dreamsicle custard, made with vanilla custard with homemade orange curd and pieces of candied orange peel. “I thought the custard and orange curd combination was good.” Many reviews also rave about their fish sandwich.

Gilles Frozen Custard – Drive-In, Milwaukee, 3.7 Stars

Address: 7515 W Bluemound Rd Milwaukee, WI 53213

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Gilles Frozen Custard has been serving up quality custard since 1938. One grateful reviewer said the process of finding just the right scoop was great. “I appreciated the option to try the custard before purchasing, which led me to split my scoop.” While some custards warn against longer wait times, it doesn’t deter them from getting great custard. “Phenomenal custard. Delicious treat for all ages and unbeatable prices. Oldest custard stand in Milwaukee – maybe in all of Wisconsin – so you know you’re getting some of the tastiest custard around here.”

Murf’s Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers, Brookfield, 3.7 Stars

Address: 12505 W Burleigh Rd Brookfield, WI 53005

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Patrons of Murf’s Frozen Custard in Brookfield praise the service and the tasty treats they offer. “Great service and great food. On our most recent visit, we enjoyed their sundae collaborations with BB Cakes – so good!” Many reviewers also had great things to say about Murf’s burgers. “The burger was delicious. It had very fresh ingredients and great flavors. The sandwiches are quite larger than regular burger places.”

Oscar’s Frozen Custard, Milwaukee, 3.7 Stars

Address: 2362 S 108th St Milwaukee, WI 53227

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: With two locations in the Milwaukee area (the address listed and a Brookfield location), you don’t want to miss out on visiting Oscar’s for fantastic frozen custard. One reviewer shares that Oscar’s is a must-visit whenever they come to town. “Every time we visit family in Wisconsin we have to get Oscar’s at some point. This frozen custard is royalty amongst all frozen custard.” The happy reviewer went on to rave, that the custard is so light and super creamy. The homemade waffle cones are wonderful with any flavor.”

Kitt’s Frozen Custard Drive-In, Milwaukee, 3.7 Stars

Address: 7000 W Capitol Dr. Milwaukee, WI 53216

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Reopened in 2023, Kitt’s is a neighborhood staple that’s been around for almost 75 years. Here, you can find exceptional customer service with every interaction and some delectable custard. “I got a double scoop strawberry cheesecake with additional strawberry topping and whipped cream. It was topped off with a cherry, of course. The customer service was so refreshing.”

Culvers, Shorewood, 3.9 Stars

Address: 1325 E Capitol Dr Shorewood, WI 53211

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Culvers is synonymous with creative flavors and quality custard. In addition to mouth-watering butter burgers, Culvers has been serving up outstanding custard for 40 years (recently celebrating its anniversary in mid-July) and has over 140 locations in Wisconsin. While all the locations and custards are incredible, one Yelper shouted out their great customer service. “I have been here before but I like to try a place more than once to make sure how everything went and every time it is consistently great. If you want great custard and food and are here, drop on by!”

Sweet Dreams, Hartland, 4.0 Stars

Address: 540 Hartbrook Dr Hartland, WI 53029

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Of the two locations in Wisconsin, this Sweet Dream shop serves up sweet treats all day long. “Their custard is delicious, and service always comes with a smile,” one Yelper said of their order. Another praised the cute location and the overall quality of their food. “Hot, fresh & homemade are just a few words to explain how amazing everything was.”

Fred’s Frozen Custard & Grill, Milwaukee, 4.2 Stars

Address: 4726 W Vliet St Milwaukee, WI 53208

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Fred’s Frozen Custard & Grill in Milwaukee is loved by regular and new customers alike. “Amazing food as always. Also, great service will continue to come back this season,” a five-star reviewer said. From burgers to BLTs and, of course, custard, there is something for everyone. One pleased reviewer wrote, “Their custard sundaes are super fun – they have so many toppings to choose from!”

Georgie Porgie’s Treefort Restaurant, Oak Creek, 4.2 Stars

Address: 9555 S Howell Ave Oak Creek, WI 53154

Price: $$

Why Yelpers Love It: Georgie Porgie’s has been around since 1991, catering to folks who want to dine in or carry out. Located in Oak Creek or Racine, the fun tree fort theme is only one of the reasons to visit this joint, which serves burgers, chicken, custard, and more. Every month, different burgers and custards are featured, with a jalapeno-stuffed pepper burger taking center stage recently. 

Leduc’s Frozen Custard, Wales, 4.4 Stars

Address: 240 W Summit Ave Wales, WI 53183

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Each day at Leduc’s, you can find vanilla, chocolate, and a unique flavor of the day custard available. Yelpers love their Leduc’s custard, with several reviews touting their treats are the best in the business. “Nothing compares. There’s delicious Wisconsin custard, and then there’s Le Duc’s in a league of its own.” One reviewer suggested trying the hot fudge shake or the custard puff. “LeDuc’s is without a doubt the gold standard for a Wisconsin frozen custard experience at its finest!”

Kopp’s Frozen Custard, Glendale, 4.4 Stars

Address: 5373 N Port Washington Rd Glendale, WI 53209

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: With three locations throughout the state, Kopp’s has been a Wisconsin treasure since 1950. While they serve burgers and other food, custard is Kopp’s claim to fame. Even our pals from Chicago and Michigan can’t get enough — Yelpers say Kopp’s delivers a proper custard that’s smoothly creamy and starts melting a bit along the edges as you eat. Another says they come up from Chicago just for their sweet treats. “So creamy, and flavorful. Consider this, dear reader… I came all the way from Chicago and one of three objectives was Kopp’s.”

Dogs & Cream, Racine, 4.5 Stars

Address: 2721 Douglas Ave Racine, WI 53402

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Dogs & Cream in Racine is unique from many other custard spots on this list. Their menu features burgers but also 11 different kinds of hot dogs like a Hotlanta dog, Big Bayou dog, Chicago dog, and more! Their custard comes in many different ways including a cone, quart, sundaes, and shakes.

Leon’s Frozen Custard, Milwaukee, 4.5 Stars

Address: 3131 S 27th St Milwaukee, WI 53215

Price: $

Why Yelpers Love It: Leon’s lasting legacy when it comes to being custard royalty is no exaggeration. Yelpers consistently write odes to the delightful, delicious custard served at Leon’s. “The texture is spot on, being thick, creamy, and dense. The butter pecan flavor here is amazing with a perfect sweetness level,” one pleased Yelper said. “The frozen custard is so smooth and creamy. They put a generous amount of fudge, pecans, and cherries. It was the perfect salty and sweet treat. This is honestly the best turtle sundae I have had. 10/10! I can see why this local frozen custard establishment has been around since 1942.”

This article first appeared on Good Info News Wire and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.