Reader-approved Wisconsin fish fries

Photo courtesy of The Old Fashioned.

By Ellie Bourdo

February 26, 2026

No matter the season, you can always find a Wisconsin restaurant serving up a fish fry.

There’s no shortage of spots to grab a fish fry in our state. We asked our readers for their favorites, and this is what we heard:

Chances Pub & Grill, Burnett

“The very best!” — Darwin B.

Highland Howie’s Pub & Grill, Green Bay

“Cozy friendly atmosphere and great old-fashions. The food no matter what you try is always good.” — Kim K.

Holy Family Parish, Whitefish Bay

“Serving over 600 meals each Friday in Lent.” — Elizabeth M.

St. Olaf Catholic Church, Eau Claire

“It’s all volunteer work by the men’s club with proceeds helping to do all the outreach things that Saint Olaf Parish is known for in our community. We serve an average of 700 plates each fish fry, with most of our clientele regulars, not parishioners and many, not even Catholic. Talk about an outreach program!” — Jay B.

Erin’s Pub ‘N’ Grub, Eagle River

“Food is delicious, very reasonable, staff are so friendly they feel like family!!!” — Tami S.

The Shop Bar & Grill, Webster

“Serves up some of the best cod and walleye fish dinners! Love the hash browns potato option with the best fish ever! Just off the intersection of County A and H.” — Daniel N.

Union Park Tavern, Kenosha

“Easily has the best Fish Fry in Kenosha.” — Kathy M.

River Street Pier, Green Bay

“Served Tuesday through Saturday, it is a win for everyone that doesn’t want to wait for Friday!” — Liz M.

St. Luke’s Catholic Church, Plain

“Family-style all-you-can-eat meal with choice of drink, batter-fried fish, tartar sauce, fried potatoes, coleslaw, cheddar cheese slices, and homemade desserts (pie, bars, etc).” — Judith B.

This Locals Love roundup first appeared in our newsletter, where we spotlight reader favorites each week. Subscribe today to catch upcoming features and share your own favorite local spots!

Author

Ellie Bourdo

Ellie Bourdo is UpNorthNews’ newsletter editor. A Wisconsin native, she was born and raised in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin and graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Madison with degrees in journalism and Spanish. In her free time, Ellie enjoys spending time with family and friends on the lake or at the ski hill. Have a story tip? Reach Ellie at [email protected]. For local reporting in Wisconsin that connects the dots, from policy to people, sign up for UpNorthNews’ "news of the day” email newsletter.

View all posts