The Green Bay Guide: Find a deal at these reader-approved thrift shops

We asked our readers to tell us their favorite Green Bay thrift shops. Here’s what they said.

Green Bay might be best known for its cheese, football, and that great northern spirit, but there’s another side to this vibrant city that thrifty shoppers know all too well: the absolute goldmine of thrift shops. Whether you’re a seasoned bargain hunter, a vintage enthusiast, or just someone looking to score some fabulous finds without breaking the bank, Green Bay has a lot to offer. According to a recent readers’ poll, three local spots have risen to the top as the best thrift shops in the city. So, grab your reusable shopping bags, put on your most comfortable shoes, and let’s dive into the best thrift shops in Green Bay.

Getty Images Signature

3. Interior Motives

2300 Lineville Rd, Green Bay, WI 54313  

Monday – Saturday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM, Sunday: Closed  

Interior Motives might just become your new obsession if you have a flair for home décor and a penchant for stylish interiors. This isn’t your typical thrift shop filled with random knick-knacks and mismatched chairs (though you might find those too if you look closely enough). Instead, Interior Motives focuses on offering well-curated, high-quality furniture and home décor items that’ll have your friends and family asking, “Where did you get that?”

One of the most exciting aspects of shopping at Interior Motives is the thrill of the hunt. You never know what you’re going to find, and that’s what makes each visit so exhilarating. One week, you might stumble upon a gorgeous mid-century modern chair that’s just begging to be the focal point of your living room. The next, it could be a rustic farmhouse table that’s perfect for hosting dinner parties. Whatever your style, there’s always something to catch your eye.

The layout of Interior Motives is one of the shop’s strong suits. It’s thoughtfully organized, with furniture and décor pieces arranged in a way that makes it easy to envision them in your own home. Everything is displayed with care, making the shopping experience both pleasant and efficient. If you’re looking to redecorate on a budget, this is the place to start.

Shopping at Interior Motives is good for your wallet and good for the planet. By purchasing second-hand furniture and décor, you’re helping to reduce waste and give these items a second life. And let’s be honest, there’s something incredibly satisfying about finding a unique piece that adds character to your home, all while knowing you scored it for a fraction of the original price.

In a city with no shortage of thrift shops, Interior Motives stands out for its focus on high-quality home furnishings and its commitment to offering a refined shopping experience. Whether you’re on the hunt for a statement piece or just browsing for inspiration, this shop is a must-visit for anyone looking to elevate their home décor without spending a fortune.

2. Home Again of Green Bay

1265 Russett Ct, Green Bay, WI 54313  

Monday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Sunday: Closed  

Home Again of Green Bay has built a reputation as the go-to spot for anyone who appreciates the charm of vintage furniture but doesn’t want their home to look like it’s stuck in a time warp. This shop strikes the perfect balance between old and new, offering pieces that have been lovingly restored or repurposed to fit seamlessly into modern homes.

One of the standout features of Home Again is its commitment to repurposing. Many of the items you’ll find here have been given a new lease on life, whether it’s a dresser that’s been refinished in a trendy shade of blue or an old door that’s been transformed into a one-of-a-kind dining table. This creative approach not only keeps the inventory fresh and exciting but also makes it easy to find something that’s truly unique.

Home Again is like a beautifully curated showroom, but better. The owners have a keen eye for design, and it shows in the way the shop is laid out. Each piece is carefully selected for its quality, character, and potential to fit into a contemporary home. Whether you’re looking for a vintage armchair to add some flair to your living room or a quirky piece of wall art to liven up your hallway, you’re sure to find something that speaks to you.

The staff at Home Again is knowledgeable and passionate about the items they sell, and they’re always happy to share the stories behind each piece. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or new to the world of second-hand shopping, you’ll feel welcome and inspired as you browse the carefully curated selection.

In a town with a competitive thrift shop scene, Home Again stands out for its commitment to quality and its unique approach to repurposing vintage furniture. If you’re looking for something with a bit of history and a lot of character, this shop is a must-visit. Plus, the friendly atmosphere and knowledgeable staff make it a pleasure to browse, even if you’re just window shopping.

1. Unity Resale Shoppe

1640 Fernando Dr, Ashwaubenon, WI 54304  

Monday – Friday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Saturday: 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM, Sunday: Closed  

Topping our list with the gold medal for thrifting is Unity Resale Shoppe, a small business with a mission that goes beyond offering great deals. Every purchase made here supports Unity Hospice, a local nonprofit that provides compassionate end-of-life care to individuals and families in the Green Bay area. So not only are you scoring amazing finds at unbeatable prices, but you’re also contributing to a cause that makes a real difference in the community.

One of the things that sets Unity Resale Shoppe apart from the competition is its incredible variety. This isn’t just a clothing thrift store or a place to pick up a few home goods. It’s a one-stop shop for just about anything you could need. From gently used furniture and stylish clothing to kitchen gadgets and quirky knick-knacks, Unity has it all.

Let’s talk about the prices (because most of us need to mind our wallets). Unity Resale Shoppe is known for its rock-bottom prices, making it the perfect destination for anyone looking to stretch their dollars. Whether you’re a college student furnishing your first apartment, a family looking for back-to-school clothes, or a thrifting enthusiast searching for your next great find, you’re guaranteed to find something that fits both your style and your budget.

The friendly staff and volunteers create a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back time and time again. Plus, the shop regularly hosts sales and special events, making it a fun and engaging place to visit. Whether you’re there to shop, donate, or just browse, you’ll leave with a smile on your face.

So, why did Unity Resale Shoppe earn the top spot in our readers’ poll? It’s simple. This shop offers an unbeatable combination of variety, value, and community impact. With every purchase supporting a worthy cause, it’s a place where you can feel good about spending your money. Add to that the incredible selection and unbeatable prices, and it’s easy to see why Unity Resale Shoppe is a favorite among Green Bay thrifters.

READ MORE: The best restaurants in Green Bay